Showing posts with label Healthcare Reform. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Healthcare Reform. Show all posts

Monday, March 9, 2009

In Healthcare Reform, Caveat Emptor

Some might take issue with this article’s title. Applying ‘”caveat emptor” (“buyer beware”) to healthcare reform presupposes that healthcare is a commodity to be bought and sold. Like other services, healthcare IS a commodity that (to an extent) NEEDS to be bought and sold.

I admittedly do not know the details of the President’s health care proposal (I can not find any), but I know what I do not want to happen. I do not want the system to lose performance (including efficiency) incentives for doctors, patients, insurers, pharmaceutical companies, and device manufacturers. While some people are altruistic, the vast majority of people (and companies) are not.

Communism failed because there was no incentive for anyone to do anything.

The same principles apply to healthcare. If all doctors are paid the same, doctors will have no incentive to be better doctors. Even further, if the exceptional doctors are not rewarded, then exceptional people will not become doctors.

People like to rail against “the obscene profits of the drug companies.” Those obscene profits are the reason that drug companies bother to invent new drugs. It is not a coincidence that most pharmaceutical research is based in the United States. Our policies reward innovation and investment. Price controls on drugs would have many undesirable “side effects.”

If health care is "free," people are more likely to run to the doctor for trivial health complaints, further clogging a system that is guaranteed to become backlogged.

Getting any non-emergency procedure would likely require getting on a long waiting list, as they have to do for non-emergency procedures in Canada and Britain. There is a reason many Canadians come to the US for non-emergency procedures, and whatever the reason (waiting list or available quality of care), it is undeniable evidence that their system is not superior to ours.

One reason our health care system is comparatively expensive is the higher availability quality of care. Competition between hospitals and health care companies spurs them to have the latest technology to diagnose and treat patients. On the other hand, if people are forced to go to your hospital, you can do without that new MRI machine. You have no incentive to retain the best doctors, who WANT to have the latest technology to treat their patients. If it is a government monopoly, where else are the patients going to go? Where else are the doctors going to go? Perhaps, they will both go to another country.

While demonized (admittedly, some criticism is valid), health insurance companies do create pressure for efficiency. Without such scrutiny, inefficiencies would never be addressed. Money and resources that could have been used to actually treat people would be wasted.

Besides, I am not sure that private health insurance is currently as cost prohibitive as many people contend. On my own, I purchased health insurance from a major insurer that is almost as good as the programs I had through employers, and it is only $114 per month, including prescription benefits and the ability to choose my own doctor. Granted, I am a single man, but I am over 40 years of age. People use Cobra all the time as an example of out of control health premiums, but Cobra is a rip-off. After leaving my last two radio companies, I had Cobra offers of $500 and $600 per month. No thanks.

As the administration embarks on their effort to sell health care reform, people need to pay attention to the details. Scanning the administration’s health care reform website (http://www.healthreform.gov/), I found it contained a lot of platitudes and nebulous goals, but concrete recommendations were conspicuously absent.

If one pays attention to the details of the administration's sell job, it gets harder to buy into the feel good hype and harder to be frightened by the scare tactics. For instance, the number of Americans who have been bankrupted by medical expenses is grossly exaggerated by the administration. (http://blogs.abcnews.com/politicalpunch/2009/03/false-talking-1.html). While a comparatively smaller number of medical bankruptcies STILL is something that needs addressing, a comparatively smaller number of bankruptcies makes the changes needed to address them much less drastic.

Socialized medicine would not be free, as proponents think it would be. It would cost.

Boy, would it cost.